ArtSeblis

pushing 60 reads a year; i'll try not to cheat

harry potter and the sorcerer’s stone by jk rowlings

with 5 comments

Overall, a charming debut about a boy wizard. But I’m glad it’s out of the way so I can move on the progressively darker sequels. And see more of  sulky Snape and gay Hagrid :P .

harry_potter_and_the_sorcerers_stone by jk rowlingDo I have to summarize the story of Harry Potter? Doesn’t everyone know about his story by now? The Boy who Survived and You-Know-Who hunting him. I’ve seen the movies, liked them increasingly by each sequel, and stopped short of being a fan. The movies were brilliant and I liked seeing the characters and actors mature, and the plot thicken, moving from the babyish fantasy of Sorcerer’s Stone to the chilling rebirth of Voldemort. I found the absolute loyalty of the evil sorcerer’s minions sick and depraved, bordering on the sexual (has anyone else noticed this?). And that stopped me yawning because seeing that in a children’s series was funny. Published in 1997, I’m only now reading the Sorcerer’s Stone, and only because I felt I had to, acquiring the book in a book swap three years ago, having promised the previous owner I’ll get back to her about my impressions of the book, and caving in from the pressure of being maybe the only one in my circle or reader-friends not to have read the book. So I added it to my TBR challenge.

And regretted it for a week, which was how long before I managed to get past page 100, finding the account of Harry’s early years, about how incredibly boring Muggles were, incredibly boring. Come to think about it, I also never did manage to finish watching the first movie, no matter how many times I’ve caught it running on cable. This was good as it turned out as I was surprised by the revelation of whodunit later in the book.

I’ve read fantasy fiction by other British authors before, such as Margaret Storey (A War of Wizards), Edith Nesbit (Psammead Series), and Tanith Lee (Unicorn series) . Their stories were extraordinary and I loved them. Until now I have a crush on Hilarion, the wizard who can’t stand to be seen. My favorite of their ilk will be forevermore Dianna Wynne Jones, who penned Howl’s Moving Castle and creator of unforgettable characters like Sophie Farthing, Wizard Howl, and the fire demon Calcifer. Having partaken of their literary feasts since high school I was not that excited over the news of a new Fantasy author and her debut work about a boy wizard.

My reading taste lately has also shifted from pure fantasy to urban fantasy, and not just because of the kick-ass heroines, but also because I prefer if the story treats magic as part of the world, not separate but one and the same, with people just experiencing different things. One reason I got bored with the first part of Sorcerer’s Stone was the strong sense of insularity it conveyed of the magic world from Muggle world.

Nevertheless, I did get past the first 100 pages and was engaged finally as Harry learned about potions, spells, and the soccer-like game Quidditch. The mystery of the Sorcerer’s Stone was interesting. I liked how the author dropped hints here and there as well, not just about the current mystery but also about the overarching mystery of Voldemort and Harry’s role in his downfall. I can imagine how like a game it is for readers spotting references and clues, connecting the dots from book 1 to book 3 or somewhere else. That was very clever of the author.

Her imaginative details were also impressive. She invented Platform 9 ¾,  Every Flavor Beans, messenger owls, and the magic puzzle game in the Sorcerer’s Stone Chamber, hearth-hatching of a dragon egg and  Quidditch. I liked how she used elements of the British school system to define Hogwarts School. The rivalry and other relationship dynamics between students and eccentric faculty were well thought out. Even if I had not seen the movies, I can easily visualize Harry, Ron, Hermione, and all the others. The writing was fluid, easily keeping pace with human and magical nuances. Spooky also had a special place; if I were 11 years old I imagined I would be terrified out of my wits upon realizing what lay under the turban.

Overall, a charming debut about a boy wizard. But I’m glad it’s out of the way so I can move on the progressively darker sequels. And see more of  sulky Snape and gay Hagrid :P .

5 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. I think you and I may be book soul mates. Your story of why you haven’t read Harry Potter rivals my own. Except I still haven’t read the 1st one (it’s on my TRS – To Read Someday – list) and I acquired the novel from a box of books a previous employer was going to get rid of. I’ve since lost the book, but a friend gave me the ebook version as a gift for my new Nook, and it has a home there…waiting…
    Also, I love Diana Wynn Jones (oh Howl and Sophie!) and Tanith Lee. I haven’t read the others, but now I’m curious. Diana Wynn Jones also made a very chilling ghost story…which I’m having trouble remembering the name (it’s late). Anyway, I also have shifted my reading tendencies to urban fantasies mostly because it’s one of the few genres that always fulfill my yearning for female heroines (that seem surrounded by hot man flesh, for the days when that’s a perk :P ) and interesting world building. Although I may be reaching my limit (bad news when you’re writing an urban fantasy series yourself!), because there’s some REALLY bad urban fantasies out there. *gag*

    Cordite Quill

    February 14, 2011 at 4:35 pm

    • Hi, Cordite! Oh my goodness, your post was over a year ago!

      So sorry, I was so caught up by work that I abandoned my blog. But I still see your stories around in Fanfiction.net and I make sure to give feedback once in a while.

      Anyway, back to Harry Potter, Dianna Wynn Jones and Tanith Lee — yes, they are awesome authors! Tanith Lee is the strangest of the lot, though, for me–she can write sweet, slightly dark YAs one moment, and then next she’s penning truly dark, depressing fantasy horrors.

      I agree with you totally about urban fantasy! Another reason I love it is that it also satisfies my craving for romance set within a fascinating, strange world. The fact that the romance is secondary to the Fantasy action usually meant the romance is drawn out–which is what I love! I prefer passionate pursuit in my romance and not immediate gratification–which I find boring.

      Do you have any favorite urban fantasy? Mine is the Kate Daniels series by Ilona Andrews.

      Of course, your Labyrinth stories are in my favorites. :D

      ArtSeblis

      August 13, 2012 at 3:15 am

  2. For years I have been trying to find the books with Hilarion in – this is the first time I’ve found a mention of him (though Heaven knows why your blog didn’t come up in previous web searches I’ve done). I was about 7 when I read the books, but have never forgotten him (it’s now some 34 years later…), though I have forgotten the author’s name. Please tell me who it was so I can start scouring Amazon & 2nd hand bookshops! Thanks.

    Evie

    March 21, 2012 at 11:36 pm

    • Hi, Evie. Sorry for replying just now. Work had been toxic and I had to leave off blogging for a while. Anyway, the author is Margaret Storey (A War of Wizards). Hope you find all her books! Please update me.

      ArtSeblis

      August 13, 2012 at 3:05 am

  3. May I simply say what a comfort to find someone that truly understands what they are talking about on the net.
    You actually know how to bring an issue to light and make it important.
    More and more people need to check this out and
    understand this side of your story. It’s surprising you’re not more popular since you surely possess the gift.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: